i fail to see how it's unfair. as callaway says, if more people than one happen to hold the same opinion, should only one of them be allowed to express it?
what you seem to be saying here is that any one of us is capable of pwning scrap (true, incidentally) and so only one of us should be allowed to do it at a time. imo, that is unfair. he's an adult, responsible for his actions. if you agree with him, help him.
as for scrap's admin days, that's a separate discussion.