I'm no weeboo by any stretch of the imagination. I usually like what anime I'm shown, though I've only seen a few series'. I usually prefer dubbed because I don't want to put that much extra effort into figuring out what will probably be a convoluted and hard-to-follow plot anyway. For example, I just finished watching eva a couple weeks ago and still only know the names of a couple of the characters. (Though, in eva, the plot wasn't the point. The point was the director was still working through his shit with the world in general and women more specifically, and being a bitch about it. Liked the series. Hated the director based on what the series said about him.)
I tend to be pretty shite about following plots in movies anyway though, especially plots with a lot of characters. Books as well, but less so, because I can pause and 'look up' what I somehow managed to miss.