It looks bad for you. He claimed that he was grandfathered in, which you didn't answer.
And that the only reason he lost it now is that you were but hurt by something else he did recently. Basically he is claiming that you are punishing him, a grown man, because he hurt your feelings.
All you said in response was a casual, no, not butt hurt.
But he evidence doesn't add up. I think he has a point. Why did he lose his suck puppet now, after all these years....especially if (as you claim) he only used it now as he had the entire time he had it.
Why now?
Because I got fed up cleaning up after the troll. I've said this a number of times. You can choose to believe it, you can choose to say I'm lying. If the latter, you'd better back up your words.
I've also said, more than once, that yes, his sock is known, it's the only one being used. Incidentally, it's only used for trolling, something that Scrap could easily do with his usual account, just as anyone else. He'd be no more incognito with the sock other than with n00bs or relative n00bs, though. Anyway, grandfathered in is sort of wrong, tolerated is more right. Until that last troll, that is. The fact is that we've not allowed any new socks to register for a long time, and the fact is that his was the only one active after March 2008 that I know of.
And no, I didn't ban it because of some imagined previous butthurt. No idea what he is referring to, tbh. If anything, before this I thought we might be civil to each other. So no; no butthurt. If you think I'm lying, back it up, mate, instead of producing vague insinuations. I know you do a lot of those and you are very good at them, but unless you have proof perhaps you'd better leave it be and admit that you don't have proof.