let me simplify it for you:
ME and ERIS KNOW the "MUGWUMP" character you dug up from the nachtkabaret forums. we KNOW the person. he isnt "just some troll"
so whoever "buttcoffee" is, buttcoffee isnt mugwump. that is something both me and eris would know for absulute sure, and no theory of yours could show otherwise, cus we KNOW that person.
now, ive no idea who "buttcoffee" is, but it most certainly isnt "mugwump"
and ive no idea if mugwump OR buttcoffee is impersonating as "charley patton"
but they are not the same person. its not open for speculation :b